Fan Coil Unit vs Split System

Nowadays, various HVAC air conditioning systems have become vital parts of building facilities. Selecting the right HVAC equipment ensures comfortable cooling during the summer, warm and cozy air in the winter, and clean, optimal indoor air. Air conditioning systems, such as split AC and fan coil, are being produced in various models to fulfill the needs of different projects based on type, capacity, climatic conditions, and building limitations. This article studies "Fan Coil vs. Air Conditioner" in terms of operation, application, energy consumption, costs, etc. So, stay with us to investigate "Fan Coil unit vs. Split System" in detail.

Fan Coil vs. Air Conditioner Unit Operational Differences One of the key differences between air conditioners and fan coil units lies in their operating and performance mechanisms. An air conditioner, also called a split AC or AC unit, is a standalone system that does not require central heating or cooling equipment like a chiller. It consists of an indoor and outdoor unit connected by two refrigerant pipes. In a compression cycle, mostly done by T1 and T3 compressors in AC units , these systems use refrigerants like R22 or R410a to independently cool or heat spaces such as rooms, halls, or residential units. On the other hand, a fan coil unit, also called an FCU unit, cannot independently cool or heat air. They rely on auxiliary systems such as mini chillers or central chillers (for cooling) and boilers or heating packages (for heating). Fan coil units offer significant flexibility, as multiple units can be installed to cater to various residential, commercial, and administrative areas, providing independent temperature control for each space. Air conditioners are ideal for smaller spaces like bedrooms, living rooms, or shops. However, their capacity limitations may necessitate the use of multiple units for larger areas, resulting in higher upfront costs. With their scalability and centralized cooling and heating support, fan coil units are better suited for larger buildings with varied usage needs.

Fan Coil vs Air Conditioner in Cooling and Heating Capacity Air conditioners are primarily used for cooling smaller spaces during hot seasons. An AC unit can also provide heating during colder months, but its high electricity consumption in heating mode often makes it less economical. Overusing split AC units throughout the year may increase the risk of breakdowns, making supplementary heating systems like boilers or radiators a more viable option for winter. Fan coil units utilize chilled water from a chiller for cooling and hot water from a boiler or heating package for warming spaces. Consistently operating cooling and heating models of FCU units offers lower energy consumption than air conditioners.

Energy Consumption in Fan Coil Unit vs Split System Air conditioner split systems rely entirely on electricity to operate both indoor and outdoor units, which requires significant energy use. Fan coil units consume less electricity since their auxiliary systems, such as boilers (powered by natural gas or other fuels) and chillers, share the energy load. For instance, the electricity consumption of a central chiller for an entire building is generally much lower than that of numerous individual air conditioners. Thus, fan coils are more energy-efficient than split ACs, particularly in large-scale installations.

FCU vs. Split Unit Impact on Building Facades An FCU relies on central equipment like chillers or boilers, which are usually hidden from view, to maintain buildings' exterior aesthetics. In contrast, a split unit's outdoor system is often mounted visibly on building facades, which can negatively affect their appearance, especially in cases where multiple units are installed.

DamaTajhiz HVAC Co., Engineering, Manufacturing, and Trading Company in the Middle East Since 2004 Review, Selection, and Pricing of HVAC Equipment Fan Coil vs. Air Conditioner in Installation Costs A fan coil (FCU) and split air conditioner (commonly known as split systems) are both HVAC systems consisting of an indoor unit and an outdoor unit. The indoor unit is installed inside the building, while the outdoor unit, usually larger, is located outside. These units are interconnected via piping for either water or refrigerant. In a split AC, the connection between the indoor and outdoor units is made through two copper pipes (supply and return) insulated with elastomeric material. These pipes circulate refrigerants such as R22 or R410a to provide cooling or heating for indoor spaces. On the other hand, a fan coil is connected to a central system, such as a chiller or mini-chiller (for cooling in summer) and a hot water boiler (for heating in winter), using two ordinary water pipes (supply and return). This cost-effectiveness, along with ease of integration into centralized systems, makes FCUs a preferred choice for large-scale projects.

Fan Coil Unit vs. Split System Fresh Air Integration As you know, the indoor unit of a split system, which is installed inside a room, only circulates the indoor air and changes (increases or decreases) its temperature, like what an AUH does. However, fan coil units include two types: ducted and non-ducted, with the ducted type gathering fresh air from outside the environment. The performance of split system air conditioners and fan coil units is similar in terms of how and to what extent humidity is removed from the air. These devices are essentially dehumidifiers. The cold surface of their internal coil causes condensation of water vapor (humidity) in the air, reducing it in the environment.

Fan Coil Unit vs. Split for Initial Purchase Costs The cost of purchasing multiple fan coil units along with all their associated equipment, such as a mini chiller or central chiller and a heating package or boiler, is not significantly different from the cost of purchasing an air conditioner with complementary equipment, such as a heating package and radiators for a similar building (small area). However, in larger buildings with more floors and over 20 units, the use of fan coils and chillers is not only technically justified but also more economical than using dozens of air conditioning units together. Air conditioners perform better in very hot and humid regions and allow for faster cooling of the indoor air. On the other hand, fan coil units are far more effective than split air conditioners in winter for heating different areas of a building.

Setup Limits of Fan Coil Unit vs. Air Conditioning System In buildings with numerous rooms or spaces, installing multiple air conditioners may be impractical due to piping and outdoor unit placement limitations. Fan coil systems, however, allow for a flexible number of units to be installed without such restrictions, making them ideal for large and complex buildings.

Note: Purchasing multiple split units for a building is not economically viable. This approach significantly increases the building's operational costs, including higher electricity consumption and unit maintenance expenses.

DamaTajhiz; The First Specialized Reference for Selection and Pricing of HVAC and Building Equipment (Since 2004)

Advantages and Disadvantages of Fan Coil vs. Split in Summary You read the comparison of air conditioners (split units) and fan coil units (FCUs) completely. For example, you learned that Air conditioners excel in quickly cooling spaces in hot and humid climates, while fan coil units are more effective at maintaining comfortable temperatures during winter. Now, it is time to review them in lists. Here are brief reviews of the advantages and disadvantages of fan coils and split AC units.

The advantages of air conditioners (split units) include:

Aesthetic Design: Sleek and visually appealing appearance. Air Filtration System: Equipped with air purification and filtration capabilities. Rapid Cooling: Quickly cools spaces, even in hot and humid climates. Remote Control Functionality: Provides convenience in remote operation. Ideal for Small Spaces: Designed for efficient cooling in compact environments. Powerful Cooling: Delivers robust cooling performance. Independent Temperature Control: Each unit allows individual temperature adjustments for different rooms. The disadvantages of air conditioners (split units) are:

High Electricity Consumption: Energy-intensive operation. Maintenance Costs: Requires regular servicing, adding to upkeep expenses. Unsuitable for Large Areas: There is limited coverage for larger spaces. This feature has not been a weakness anymore since ducted splits have come. Restricted Heating Performance: Limited capacity for heating during winter. Installation Limitations: Placement constraints during installation. Impact on Building Aesthetics: Outdoor units can negatively affect the building's exterior appearance. The advantages of fan coil units (FCUs) include:

Quiet Operation: Operates with minimal noise. No Ductwork Required: Simplifies installation by eliminating the need for duct systems. Fresh Air Integration: Enables the introduction of fresh air into indoor spaces. Versatile for Large Buildings: Suitable for use in expansive structures. Dual Functionality: Efficient in both cooling and heating. Room-Specific Temperature Control: Allows independent climate control for each room. Scalability: Supports simultaneous operation of multiple FCUs within a building. Longevity: Durable with a long operational lifespan. Energy Efficiency: It consumes less electricity compared to split units. Lower Maintenance Costs: Economical in terms of servicing and upkeep. The disadvantages of fan coil units (FCUs) are:

Ceiling Installation Constraints: Placement in false ceilings can limit room height, particularly with ceiling and cassette units. Increased Noise at High Capacities: Larger units like ducted FCUs may produce more noise.

An Overview of Fan Coil vs. Air Conditioners by DamaTajhiz Experts The discussion above shows that air conditioners (split units) are more suitable for small spaces and provide adequate cooling in hot and humid regions. However, they may not be ideal for large buildings due to limited heating capabilities and high energy consumption. On the other hand, fan coil units (FCUs) are highly efficient for larger spaces such as residential complexes, office buildings, commercial centers, hospitals, and more. Their cost-effectiveness, scalability, and ability to provide both cooling and heating make them a more practical and economical choice for such applications.

About DamaTajhiz HVAC Co. DamaTajhiz offers up-to-date technical information and competitive pricing on hundreds of models from top brands of split air conditioners and fan coil units. With golden warranties, authenticity guarantees, and responsive after-sales services, our platform ensures a smooth and informed purchasing experience. Feel free to contact our experts in the HVAC equipment department during business hours for personalized consultations and additional comparisons tailored to your specific project needs.

"Knowledge Fuels Better Choices"

Registered Trademark and Stewardship Business Licenses Issued by the Union of Virtual Business Association and the HVAC Equipment Industry. DamaTajhiz HVAC Participation at International HVAC and Construction Facilities Exhibitions Demonstrates its Global Reach and Commitment to the Industry.